| |
  
ACTD A unified effort
by all participants
Outrider
By comparison, the TUAV ACTD (Outrider) evolved from an already-planned
acquisition program, the Maneuver UAV. It faced the challenge of meeting
both Army and maritime requirements with one air vehicle while meeting strict
production unit cost thresholds. Also, it was perceived as an off-the-shelf
system, both to enable early fielding and to meet cost limits. Thus, when
significant engineering was required to meet range, engine and shipboard
suitability goals, the program fell several months behind schedule. Since
that time, a dozen successful flights have both validated its key subsystems
and identified capabilities that were too hard to attain in
a timely manner. For example, a gasoline engine has replaced the heavy fuel
engine (HFE) option for the balance of the ACTD, with further HFE development
to be consolidated in a separate effort.
HAE UAVs
In contrast, both Global Hawk and DarkStar were envisioned
from the start as needing significant development to work as systems. On
the other hand, the operational capabilities projected for each vehicle
offered such operational benefits that, if the ACTD approach could enable
an early assessment of their military worth, higher risks were well warranted.
During this past year, both programs experienced delays for technical problems,
but the year delay for each program will still enable their operational
evaluation several years earlier than a traditional acquisition program.
A more general set of ACTD lessons learned is listed below.5

5 See also RAND study MR-899-OSD,
The Predator ACTD: A Case Study for Transition Planning to the Formal Acquisition
Process, to be published Fall 1997.
   |