PDF Version


69-006

110TH CONGRESS

REPORT

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

2d Session

110-665

--INTELLIGENCE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2009

MAY 21, 2008- Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the State of the Union and ordered to be printed

Mr. REYES, from the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, submitted the following

R E P O R T

together with

MINORITY VIEWS

[To accompany H.R. 5959]

[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]

CONTENTS Page
H.R. 5959, as reported to House 1
Purpose 30
Overall Perspective on the Classified Annex and Committee Intent 31
Scope of Committee Review 31
Committee Statement and Views 31
Overview
31
Committee Review
32
The Legislation
32
Areas of Special Interest
34
Comprehensive National Cybersecurity Initiative
34
Overreliance on Supplemental Funding
35
Human Intelligence Capability Throughout the World
35
Issues Regarding Committee Notification of Syria's Nuclear Program
36
Amendments to the National Security Act of 1947
36
Diversity in the Intelligence Community
37
Committee Investigation into the Destruction of Interrogation Videotapes by the Central Intelligence Agency
37
Creation of a National Applications Office in the Department of Homeland Security
38
Major Systems Acquisitions
38
Acquisition Program Performance Notification
39
Advanced Research and Development
39
Future Course for Overhead Architecture
40
Integration of the Counterintelligence Field Activity into the Defense Intelligence Agency
40
FBI's Use of National Security Letters
41
Global Climate Change
42
Committee Consideration and Roll Call Votes 42
Section-by-Section Analysis and Explanation of the Amendment 46
Title I--Intelligence
46
Section 101--Authorization of appropriations
46
Section 102--Classified Schedule of Authorizations
46
Section 103--Personnel ceiling adjustments
46
Section 104--Intelligence Community Management Account
46
Section 105--Limitation on the use of covert action funds
47
Section 106--Prohibition on use of funds to implement `Five and Out' program of the Federal Bureau of Investigation
47
Title II--Central Intelligence Agency Retirement and Disability System
47
Section 201--Authorization of appropriations 47
Section 202--Technical modification to mandatory retirement provision of the Central Intelligence Agency Retirement Act
47
Title III--General Provisions
47
Section 301--Increase in employee compensation and benefits authorized by law
47
Section 302--Enhanced flexibility in non-reimbursable details to elements of the Intelligence Community
47
Section 303--Multi-level security clearances
48
Section 304--Delegation of authority for travel on common carriers for intelligence collection personnel
48
Section 305--Annual personnel level assessments for the Intelligence Community
48
Section 306--Comprehensive report on intelligence community contractors
49
Section 307--Report on proposed pay-for-performance intelligence community personnel management system
50
Section 308--Report on plan to increase diversity within the Intelligence Community
50
Section 309--Report on security clearance determinations
51
Section 311--Restriction on conduct of intelligence activities
51
Section 312--Clarification of definition of Intelligence Community under the National Security Act of 1947
51
Section 313--Modification of availability of funds for different intelligence activities
51
Section 314--Protection of certain national security information
52
Section 315--Extension of authority to delete information about receipt and disposition of foreign gifts and decorations
52
Section 316--Report on compliance with the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005 and related provisions of the Military Commissions Act of 2006
53
Section 317--Incorporation of reporting requirements
54
Section 318--Repeal of certain reporting requirements
54
Section 319--Enhancement of critical skills training program
54
Section 320--Comprehensive national cybersecurity initiative advisory panel
54
Title IV--Matters Relating To Elements of the Intelligence Community
54
Section 401--Clarification of limitation on co-location of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence
54
Section 402--Membership of the Director of National Intelligence on the Transportation Security Oversight Board
55
Section 403--Additional duties of the Director of Science and Technology
55
Section 404--Leadership and location of certain offices and officials
55
Section 405--Plan to implement recommendations of the data center energy efficiency reports
55
Section 406--Semiannual reports on the nuclear programs of Iran, Syria, and North Korea
56
Section 407--Title of Chief Information Officer of the Intelligence Community
56
Section 408--Inspector General of the Intelligence Community
56
Section 409--Annual report on foreign language proficiency in the Intelligence Community
58
Section 410--Repeal of certain authorities relating to the office of the National Counterintelligence Executive
58
Section 411--National Intelligence Estimate on weapons of mass destruction in Syria
58
Section 412--Annual report on intelligence resources dedicated to Iraq and Afghanistan
59
Section 413--Ombudsman for intelligence community security clearances
59
Section 414--Security clearance reciprocity
59
Section 415--Report on international traffic in arms regulations
59
Section 416--Report on nuclear trafficking
59
Section 417--Study on revoking pensions of persons who commit unauthorized disclosures of classified information
60
Section 421--Review of covert action programs by Inspector General of the Central Intelligence Agency
60
Section 422--Inapplicability to the Director of the Central Intelligence Agency of requirement for annual report on progress in auditable financial statements
60
Section 423--Technical amendments relating to titles of certain CIA positions
61
Section 424--Clarifying amendments relating to Section 105 of the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2004
61
Section 425--Prohibition on the use of private contractors for interrogations involving person in the custody or control of the Central Intelligence Agency
61
Section 431--Integration of the Counterintelligence Field Activity into the Defense Intelligence Agency
61
Section 441--Clarification of inclusion of the Coast Guard and Drug Enforcement Administration as elements of the Intelligence Community
62
Section 442--Report on transformation of the intelligence capabilities of the Federal Bureau of Investigation
62
Title V--Other Matters
63
Section 501--Extension of National Commission for Review of Research and Development Programs of the United States Intelligence Community
63
Section 502--Amendments to the National Security Act of 1947
63
Section 503--Report on financial intelligence on terrorist assets
63
Section 504--Notice of intelligence regarding North Korea and China
63
Section 505--Sense of Congress regarding use of intelligence resources
64
Section 511--Technical amendments to the Central Intelligence Agency Act of 1949
64
Section 512--Technical amendments to the multi-year National Intelligence Program
64
Section 513--Technical clarifications of certain references to Joint Military Intelligence Program and Tactical Intelligence and Related Activities
64
Section 514--Technical Amendments to the National Security Act of 1947
64
Section 515--Technical amendments to the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004
64
Section 516--Technical amendments to the Executive Schedule
64
Section 517--Technical amendments relating to the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency
65
Correspondence with Other Committees Regarding Particular Provisions 65
Letter from Chairman Berman to Chairman Reyes 65
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Chairman Berman 65
Letter from Chairman Skelton to Chairman Reyes 66
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Chairman Skelton 67
Letter from Chairman Thompson to Chairman Reyes 67
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Chairman Thompson 68
Letter from Chairman Conyers to Chairman Reyes 68
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Chairman Conyers 69
Letter from Chairman Waxman to Chairman Reyes 69
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Chairman Waxman 70
Correspondence with Congressional Budget Office 71
Letter from Chairman Reyes to Mr. Peter Orszag, Director 71
Letter from Mr. Orszag to Chairman Reyes 71
Congressional Budget Office Estimate 71
Changes to Existing Law 73
Minority Views 114

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.

Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
TITLE I--BUDGET AND PERSONNEL AUTHORIZATIONS
Sec. 101. Authorization of appropriations.
Sec. 102. Classified Schedule of Authorizations.
Sec. 103. Personnel ceiling adjustments.
Sec. 104. Intelligence Community Management Account.
Sec. 105. Limitation on the use of covert action funds.
Sec. 106. Prohibition on use of funds to implement `5 and out' program of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
TITLE II--CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY RETIREMENT AND DISABILITY SYSTEM
Sec. 201. Authorization of appropriations.
Sec. 202. Technical modification to mandatory retirement provision of the Central Intelligence Agency Retirement Act.
TITLE III--GENERAL INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY MATTERS
Subtitle A--Personnel Matters
Sec. 301. Increase in employee compensation and benefits authorized by law.
Sec. 302. Enhanced flexibility in nonreimbursable details to elements of the intelligence community.
Sec. 303. Multi-level security clearances.
Sec. 304. Delegation of authority for travel on common carriers for intelligence collection personnel.
Sec. 305. Annual personnel level assessments for the intelligence community.
Sec. 306. Comprehensive report on intelligence community contractors.
Sec. 307. Report on proposed pay for performance intelligence community personnel management system.
Sec. 308. Report on plans to increase diversity within the intelligence community.
Sec. 309. Report on security clearance determinations.
Subtitle B--Other Matters
Sec. 311. Restriction on conduct of intelligence activities.
Sec. 312. Clarification of definition of intelligence community under the National Security Act of 1947.
Sec. 313. Modification of availability of funds for different intelligence activities.
Sec. 314. Protection of certain national security information.
Sec. 315. Extension of authority to delete information about receipt and disposition of foreign gifts and decorations.
Sec. 316. Report on compliance with the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005 and related provisions of the Military Commissions Act of 2006.
Sec. 317. Incorporation of reporting requirements.
Sec. 318. Repeal of certain reporting requirements.
Sec. 319. Enhancement of critical skills training program.
Sec. 320. Comprehensive national cybersecurity initiative advisory panel.
TITLE IV--MATTERS RELATING TO ELEMENTS OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY
Subtitle A--Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Sec. 401. Clarification of limitation on colocation of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.
Sec. 402. Membership of the Director of National Intelligence on the Transportation Security Oversight Board.
Sec. 403. Additional duties of the Director of Science and Technology.
Sec. 404. Leadership and location of certain offices and officials.
Sec. 405. Plan to implement recommendations of the data center energy efficiency reports.
Sec. 406. Semiannual reports on nuclear programs of Iran, Syria, and North Korea.
Sec. 407. Title of Chief Information Officer of the Intelligence Community.
Sec. 408. Inspector General of the Intelligence Community.
Sec. 409. Annual report on foreign language proficiency in the intelligence community.
Sec. 410. Repeal of certain authorities relating to the Office of the National Counterintelligence Executive.
Sec. 411. National intelligence estimate on weapons of mass destruction in Syria.
Sec. 412. Report on intelligence resources dedicated to Iraq and Afghanistan.
Sec. 413. Ombudsman for intelligence community security clearances.
Sec. 414. Security clearance reciprocity.
Sec. 415. Report on international traffic in arms regulations.
Sec. 416. Report on nuclear trafficking.
Sec. 417. Study on revoking pensions of persons who commit unauthorized disclosures of classified information.
Subtitle B--Central Intelligence Agency
Sec. 421. Review of covert action programs by Inspector General of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Sec. 422. Inapplicability to Director of the Central Intelligence Agency of requirement for annual report on progress in auditable financial statements.
Sec. 423. Technical amendments relating to titles of certain Central Intelligence Agency positions.
Sec. 424. Clarifying amendments relating to section 105 of the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2004.
Sec. 425. Prohibition on the use of private contractors for interrogations involving persons in the custody or control of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Subtitle C--Defense Intelligence Components
Sec. 431. Integration of the Counterintelligence Field Activity into the Defense Intelligence Agency.
Subtitle D--Other Elements
Sec. 441. Clarification of inclusion of Coast Guard and Drug Enforcement Administration as elements of the intelligence community.
Sec. 442. Report on transformation of the intelligence capabilities of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
TITLE V--OTHER MATTERS
Subtitle A--General Intelligence Matters
Sec. 501. Extension of National Commission for the Review of the Research and Development Programs of the United States Intelligence Community.
Sec. 502. Amendments to the National Security Act of 1947.
Sec. 503. Report on financial intelligence on terrorist assets.
Sec. 504. Notice of intelligence regarding North Korea and China.
Sec. 505. Sense of Congress regarding use of intelligence resources.
Subtitle B--Technical Amendments
Sec. 511. Technical amendment to the Central Intelligence Agency Act of 1949.
Sec. 512. Technical amendments relating to the multiyear National Intelligence Program.
Sec. 513. Technical clarification of certain references to Joint Military Intelligence Program and Tactical Intelligence and Related Activities.
Sec. 514. Technical amendments to the National Security Act of 1947.
Sec. 515. Technical amendments to the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004.
Sec. 516. Technical amendments to the Executive Schedule.
Sec. 517. Technical amendments relating to the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.

SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.

TITLE I--BUDGET AND PERSONNEL AUTHORIZATIONS

SEC. 101. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.

SEC. 102. CLASSIFIED SCHEDULE OF AUTHORIZATIONS.

SEC. 103. PERSONNEL CEILING ADJUSTMENTS.

SEC. 104. INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY MANAGEMENT ACCOUNT.

SEC. 105. LIMITATION ON THE USE OF COVERT ACTION FUNDS.

SEC. 106. PROHIBITION ON USE OF FUNDS TO IMPLEMENT `5 AND OUT' PROGRAM OF THE FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION.

TITLE II--CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY RETIREMENT AND DISABILITY SYSTEM

SEC. 201. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.

SEC. 202. TECHNICAL MODIFICATION TO MANDATORY RETIREMENT PROVISION OF THE CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY RETIREMENT ACT.

TITLE III--GENERAL INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY MATTERS

Subtitle A--Personnel Matters

SEC. 301. INCREASE IN EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION AND BENEFITS AUTHORIZED BY LAW.

SEC. 302. ENHANCED FLEXIBILITY IN NONREIMBURSABLE DETAILS TO ELEMENTS OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

SEC. 303. MULTI-LEVEL SECURITY CLEARANCES.

SEC. 304. DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY FOR TRAVEL ON COMMON CARRIERS FOR INTELLIGENCE COLLECTION PERSONNEL.

SEC. 305. ANNUAL PERSONNEL LEVEL ASSESSMENTS FOR THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

`ANNUAL PERSONNEL LEVEL ASSESSMENT FOR THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY

`Sec. 506B. Annual personnel level assessment for the intelligence community.'.

SEC. 306. COMPREHENSIVE REPORT ON INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY CONTRACTORS.

SEC. 307. REPORT ON PROPOSED PAY FOR PERFORMANCE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT SYSTEM.

SEC. 308. REPORT ON PLANS TO INCREASE DIVERSITY WITHIN THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

SEC. 309. REPORT ON SECURITY CLEARANCE DETERMINATIONS.

`REPORT ON SECURITY CLEARANCE DETERMINATIONS

`Sec. 508. Report on security clearance determinations.'.

Subtitle B--Other Matters

SEC. 311. RESTRICTION ON CONDUCT OF INTELLIGENCE ACTIVITIES.

SEC. 312. CLARIFICATION OF DEFINITION OF INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY UNDER THE NATIONAL SECURITY ACT OF 1947.

SEC. 313. MODIFICATION OF AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS FOR DIFFERENT INTELLIGENCE ACTIVITIES.

SEC. 314. PROTECTION OF CERTAIN NATIONAL SECURITY INFORMATION.

SEC. 315. EXTENSION OF AUTHORITY TO DELETE INFORMATION ABOUT RECEIPT AND DISPOSITION OF FOREIGN GIFTS AND DECORATIONS.

SEC. 316. REPORT ON COMPLIANCE WITH THE DETAINEE TREATMENT ACT OF 2005 AND RELATED PROVISIONS OF THE MILITARY COMMISSIONS ACT OF 2006.

SEC. 317. INCORPORATION OF REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.

SEC. 318. REPEAL OF CERTAIN REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.

SEC. 319. ENHANCEMENT OF CRITICAL SKILLS TRAINING PROGRAM.

`INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY ACQUISITION OF CRITICAL SKILLS

`Sec. 1022. Intelligence community acquisition of critical skills.'.

SEC. 320. COMPREHENSIVE NATIONAL CYBERSECURITY INITIATIVE ADVISORY PANEL.

TITLE IV--MATTERS RELATING TO ELEMENTS OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY

Subtitle A--Office of the Director of National Intelligence

SEC. 401. CLARIFICATION OF LIMITATION ON COLOCATION OF THE OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE.

SEC. 402. MEMBERSHIP OF THE DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON THE TRANSPORTATION SECURITY OVERSIGHT BOARD.

SEC. 403. ADDITIONAL DUTIES OF THE DIRECTOR OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY.

SEC. 404. LEADERSHIP AND LOCATION OF CERTAIN OFFICES AND OFFICIALS.

SEC. 405. PLAN TO IMPLEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE DATA CENTER ENERGY EFFICIENCY REPORTS.

SEC. 406. SEMIANNUAL REPORTS ON NUCLEAR PROGRAMS OF IRAN, SYRIA, AND NORTH KOREA.

`SEMIANNUAL REPORTS ON THE NUCLEAR PROGRAMS OF IRAN, SYRIA, AND NORTH KOREA

`Sec. 509. Semiannual reports on the nuclear programs of Iran, Syria, and North Korea.'.

SEC. 407. TITLE OF CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICER OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

SEC. 408. INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

`INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY

`Sec. 103H. Inspector General of the Intelligence Community.'.

SEC. 409. ANNUAL REPORT ON FOREIGN LANGUAGE PROFICIENCY IN THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY.

`REPORT ON FOREIGN LANGUAGE PROFICIENCY IN THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY

`Sec. 510. Report on foreign language proficiency in the intelligence community.'.

SEC. 410. REPEAL OF CERTAIN AUTHORITIES RELATING TO THE OFFICE OF THE NATIONAL COUNTERINTELLIGENCE EXECUTIVE.

SEC. 411. NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE ESTIMATE ON WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION IN SYRIA.

SEC. 412. REPORT ON INTELLIGENCE RESOURCES DEDICATED TO IRAQ AND AFGHANISTAN.

SEC. 413. OMBUDSMAN FOR INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY SECURITY CLEARANCES.

`OMBUDSMAN FOR INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY SECURITY CLEARANCES

`Sec. 103I. Ombudsman for intelligence community security clearances.'.

SEC. 414. SECURITY CLEARANCE RECIPROCITY.

SEC. 415. REPORT ON INTERNATIONAL TRAFFIC IN ARMS REGULATIONS.

SEC. 416. REPORT ON NUCLEAR TRAFFICKING.

SEC. 417. STUDY ON REVOKING PENSIONS OF PERSONS WHO COMMIT UNAUTHORIZED DISCLOSURES OF CLASSIFIED INFORMATION.

Subtitle B--Central Intelligence Agency

SEC. 421. REVIEW OF COVERT ACTION PROGRAMS BY INSPECTOR GENERAL OF THE CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY.

SEC. 422. INAPPLICABILITY TO DIRECTOR OF THE CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY OF REQUIREMENT FOR ANNUAL REPORT ON PROGRESS IN AUDITABLE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.

SEC. 423. TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS RELATING TO TITLES OF CERTAIN CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY POSITIONS.

SEC. 424. CLARIFYING AMENDMENTS RELATING TO SECTION 105 OF THE INTELLIGENCE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2004.

SEC. 425. PROHIBITION ON THE USE OF PRIVATE CONTRACTORS FOR INTERROGATIONS INVOLVING PERSONS IN THE CUSTODY OR CONTROL OF THE CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY.

Subtitle C--Defense Intelligence Components

SEC. 431. INTEGRATION OF THE COUNTERINTELLIGENCE FIELD ACTIVITY INTO THE DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY.