
DATE=12/20/1999 TYPE=BACKGROUND REPORT TITLE=YEARENDER: U-S RUSSIA (CQ) NUMBER=5-45068 BYLINE=DEBORAH TATE DATELINE=WHITE HOUSE CONTENT= VOICED AT: INTRO: Disagreements over NATO's bombing campaign in Yugoslavia -- and Russia's military offensive in Chechnya -- chilled relations between Washington and Moscow in 1999 to the lowest levels since the Cold War. Despite the disagreements, U-S policy toward Russia has not changed. Correspondent Deborah Tate looks back on a year of strained relations. Text: As 1999 began, the Clinton administration became increasingly concerned by what it described as a sustained campaign of ethnic cleansing by the Serbs against ethnic Albanians in Kosovo, and it mobilized international support for intervention to stop the Serb actions. But Russia vehemently opposed using military action against its traditional Serb allies. Russian Prime Minister Yevgeny Primakov, en route to Washington in March, was so incensed when Vice President Al Gore alerted him that NATO bombing raids over Yugoslavia could begin during his visit to the United States, that he ordered his plane to make a U- turn back to Moscow. Shortly thereafter, NATO's bombing campaign began. The move would anger Russia for the remainder of the year, even though it played a key role in finding a diplomatic solution to the matter. In June, a deal was reached that paved the way for U-N peacekeepers - including Russians - to enter Kosovo as Serb troops pulled out. President Clinton was quick to hail the terms of the agreement. /// FIRST CLINTON ACTUALITY /// They provide for unity of command, they provide for a significant range of responsibilities for the Russians, which I think are entirely appropriate, and will enhance the mission's effectiveness. /// END ACT /// But U-S-Russian ties remained strained - and Moscow's decision to rush its troops in to Pristina before the other international peacekeepers reached Kosovo did not help. There were other concerns. A banking and corruption scandal linked to top Kremlin officials worried Washington. Plans by the United States to amend the Anti-Ballistic Missile treaty infuriated Moscow. A more serious disagreement surfaced as the year drew to a close on the issue of Russia's military campaign in Chechnya. Moscow defended the operation as necessary to root out Islamic insurgents intent on destabilizing the region. But with civilian casualties mounting, Mr. Clinton argued that Russia's tactics would not succeed - a point he underscored at a summit of the Organization of Security and Cooperation in Europe in Istanbul in November. /// SECOND CLINTON ACTUALITY /// I would never criticize anyone taking vigorous action against terrorism. That is very important. The real question is whether or not the nature of this uprising in Chechnya can be solved exclusively by military strategy. You can sense in this audience that it is not just the United States, it is virtually all the Europeans do not believe an exclusively military strategy can prevail; (they think) that it will lead to greater than necessary civilian casualties and greater than necessary refugees. /// END ACT /// Russian President Boris Yeltsin denounced the international criticism as meddling in Russia's internal affairs. He told the West not to lecture Moscow about civilian casualties in Chechnya after NATO's bombs killed civilians in Yugoslavia. Speaking through a translator, Mr. Yeltsin also addressed the matter at the O-S-C-E meeting in Istanbul. /// YELTSIN ACTUALITY /// We all know what disproportionate consequences such interference can cause, suffice it to recall the aggression of NATO headed by the United States that was mounted against Yugoslavia. Now, on the threshold of a new era, it is more urgent than ever before that our principal commandment for our joint efforts in Europe should be `do no harm'. /// END ACT /// But Mr. Clinton warned later that the Russian offensive would take its toll on Moscow through a loss of international prestige and by alienating investors. /// THIRD CLINTON ACTUALITY /// Russia will pay a heavy price for its actions. With each passing day, sinking more deeply into a morass that will intensify extremism and diminish its own standing in the world. /// END ACT /// Despite European pressure, Mr. Clinton has opposed cutting off U-S aid to Russia, saying it is not in Washington's interest. He notes that such assistance is supporting Russian efforts to dismantle its nuclear arsenal and carry out democratic reform - efforts the United States does not want to see jeopardized. For the time being, U-S policy toward Russia remains on course - with U-S officials hoping that engagement with Moscow will keep its economic and democratic transformation on track, and that international pressure will lead Russian officials to seek a diplomatic solution to the situation in Chechnya. (Signed) NEB/DAT/TVM/gm 20-Dec-1999 18:51 PM EDT (20-Dec-1999 2351 UTC) NNNN Source: Voice of America .